Did HHS Bury the CMS Actuary Report?

by Benjamin Domenech on 9:10 am April 27, 2010


Some corners of the internet are buzzing today about this American Spectator story, claiming that HHS Sec. Kathleen Sebelius buried the latest CMS actuary report under a rock until after Congress voted.

Sorry, but like so many other items to emerge over the years from “The Prowler” — essentially, where AmSpec sticks items with no named sources — I just do not believe this is an accurate description of what happened. A couple of reasons:

-The idea that HHS would go into what the source describes as “lockdown” over a report which essentially says the same thing prior CMS reports said (once more, with feeling) is ludicrous.
-There’s a good 25% of the report in question which couldn’t have been written “more than a week” in advance of the House vote, because it outlines portions handled via reconciliation which were quite unclear at the time.
-It’s not like CMS lacks the ability to leak something to the press if they really wanted to in advance of the vote.
-Red herring: CMS’s position is never the official position of an Administration.

Is it possible Sebelius’ staff did this? Of course. But get multiple sources, or I don’t believe it.

Update: Jake Tapper talked to the Medicare actuary, and guess what: he says it’s totally false. He didn’t even have the bill in its analytical form until March 18th. Total bupkus from “The Prowler” once again.

Follow Ben Domenech on Twitter.

Previous post:

Next post: